Walnut Bottom Diner in Carlisle

The food is good, but if you get a take-out order, you need to check it before you leave. I placed an order for a sandwich and coleslaw. I asked if the sandwich could be cut in half. It was not cut in half and a couple things were missing from the sandwich. Also, with coleslaw we should have been given utensils. They were missing along with napkins.

Service and food were good, enjoyed my 2am visit. Will return again and hopefully it stays a 5-star for me.

My husband and I stopped in here today and were really not impressed. They were pretty unfriendly, the service was slow, and the food was not good. The food was expensive, especially for the portion sizes and the fact that everything had a weird taste to it. I had some cheese ravioli that felt more like plastic than any kind of cheese. We also tried their “Disco Fries,” which are fries with cheese and gravy. It must have been the wrong kind of gravy or sat out to get congealed or something. We were handed the check and the waitress walked away without saying anything. It was awkward trying to figure out if we were supposed to go up front to pay or not. She even came back, passive aggressively took our plates, and walked away without saying anything a second time. Really wouldn’t recommend this place.

My fiance and I grabbed dinner here tonight while staying in town with a friend and we were completely blown away! The service was outstanding and so was the food and portion sizes. She had the broiled scallops and I had the broiled stuffed flounder and they were both delicious! They even gave my fiance 10% off for Veteran's Day, but they said they give veterans 10% off EVERY day!! We highly recommend the Walnut Bottom Diner 👍👍

Fast seating, even with our large party. Very fast service of excellent food. Good prices.

What an awesome diner. We got right in, food was plentiful, served quickly and it was delicious. I didn't catch our waitresses name, but she was wonderful. Probably the best waitress I've had in my life. Thank you for an amazing breakfast, our group really enjoyed it before hitting the fairground.

During breakfast hours, the food comes out astonishingly quick, like they knew what we were ordering before we did. Fairly standard diner dishes, no standouts on our many visits but no regrets either.

Though I haven't tried everything, I've really enjoyed what I have gotten at Walnut Bottom. Huge selection of options, great service, and conveniently located right off I-81, it's a great place for a meal, a snack, desserts, or just a cup of coffee.

A great find. We were on our way back North and saw the restaurant. Good food and service.

Fast and Friendly service. It is nice that the staff actually wants to interact with the customers

I have never had bad service or food here.

Great food and Great Prices Wonderful People ❤️🌈 ..

Great diner with good prices and good food. Owned by the same people who own Silver Springs Diner in Mechanicsburg. Good location.

Food was great and prices were reasonable.

Server was great. Food was good

Food was absolutely delish. My family came in to see my father at manor care and the diner is right next to it. Spent the weekend ordering take out and it was all very good.

Ordered soup as an appetizer and Reuben special. Everything came out at once. I mentioned to the waitress you usually get the app 1st then the meal. She said no it's comes out all at the same time. I explained when I get done with the soup my meal would be cold. When paying the bill the cashier NEVER asked if everything was ok. Not a very good experience

Great great customers, good food. Amazingly affordable and most of all,super delicious. Dining no where else throughout my stay here.

The food was amazing even Gordon Ramsey would approve of that

Staff was all very nice, food was excellent and I will go back next week. Maybe a new Breakfast and Lunch choice.

Fast service, excellent food. friendly staff all around great place to eat.

Food is great & very reasonably priced. Service is fast & friendly.

You gotta eat here! Great food and service. Huge portions and great prices!

Still the greatest service as it was before Covid

Had the ceaser salad with chicken breast, very good, great service

Did they change owners? My favorite wait staffers were missing. My waiter did not know how to make a vanilla milkshake! It was awful and food quality has gone downhill. I will not return.

Open 24/7 its diner food. Been he multiple times. Serive depends on how busy they are. Fair priced good food.

I've been here twice and both times have been a good experience.The first time I came was with a couple friends and the 2nd time was with a group of about 12 people. In both cases, the wait staff were very friendly and helpful and the food was great.Highly recommended.

Very good food and enjoyable experience.

Great portions, good price, solid value...nice staff

Best fried seafood combo I’ve ever had and the Reuben panini meal was excellent as well. Excellent service and very reasonable prices. I can’t wait to dine here again.

I loveed it best service ever cant wait to go again

First time visiting this diner and was extremely happy!! Great food and large portions. Large selection to choose from as well. Will surely be back!!

Our favorite diner in town. Unbelievably huge menu and perfect, fast food almost every single time. Staff is always friendly too.

Food was okay. The service was terrible we had to go and get our own silverware as our hostess nor our server provided any. We were not checked on after we got our meals. The shrimp basket were tiny little cocktail shrimp coated with a thick breading. The party melt was greasy. The only thing that was good were the fries.

The place was a bit crowded when we arrived but we were able to be seated as soon as we arrived. The waitress was very nice and patient when we were ordering our food and gave some good advice on what was good. The food came out really quickly for how crowded it was. Everything that we ordered was delicious and filling. When we got our food it was quite a lot of food and we were happy that we had more than enough to stuff ourselves and even have extra for a whole meal of leftovers. This place was definitely worth our time and money.

Travellers, this is an excellent local diner with a wonderful vintage feel and a classic diner menu that hits all the right notes. There are the Greek classics as well as modern diner food. The sandwiches are fantastic and so is anything off the specials menu. We recommend the trout and flounder. It is worth the stop. Check it out. We recommend.

We had a great waitress and food is always good!!

The seafood was fresh and delicious. The roast beef was tasteless, the gravy pasty ,served over dry white. Make a better gravy on a better bread and chip the beef. The waitress was friendly and attentive.

Love. This place. Food is delicious and staff are very friendly. Feels like home. Thank you to the owners

Wonderful hospitality, good food, friendly people

Amazing dinner, great food fun and understanding staff. Food presentation was excellent

They always give quite a bit of food and very very good

Eh, it was ok. Wouldn't be interested in going again.

Good breakfast. Good prices. Friendly service. Food hot and prompt. Home fries are the best done ans crispy. Could not wait to eat.

We stopped here cause it seemed interesting as we were passing through on a road trip. It was so amazing! I got the french toast and my boyfriend got the biscuits and gravy. The portions were out of this world! And it was delicious! Will be stopping here again if we ever come through!

Great selection of comfort foods, etc. cooked to perfection...enjoyed chipped beef on toast & scrapple that I haven't had for 20+ years since moving to Michigan...this restaurant is an excellent addition to the dining experience that Carlisle has to offer.

Good food. Service was good. Server was attentive and polite.

There is a waitress and cook on night shift that is absolutely awesome! B4 this covid struck i loved going there after a tiring day of work cuz they fast, courteous, my waitress sarcastic yet to the point. Lol... and the food was perfect. I give only 3 stars for day time food when they did away with night service temporarily cuz the service and food just does not compare to the almighty night shift. Cant wait for night to open up again! P.s. the prices and portions r fabu overall.

The food was very good and the menu was extensive. I thought the prices were very reasonable. My server was friendly and provided good service. I stopped here because this restaurant is conveniently located one block from exit 45 on Interstate 81. They have a large parking lot.